| Awardee | Award / Office
| Year |
| Michael A. Barbieri | Pirate Club | 2009 |
| Anthony Panto | Pirate Club | 2009 |
| Joseph Jaep | Pirate Club | 2009 |
| Nicholas Martino | Pirate Club | 2009 |
| Louis Spadaccini | Pirate Club | 2009 |
| Scott M. Oster | Pirate Club | 2009 |
| Carl Arrigale | Pirate Club | 2009 |
| Anthony DellaPia | Pirate Club | 2009 |
| Robert Santore | Pirate Club | 2008 |
| Edward J. Allen | Pirate Club | 2008 |
| Joseph Fox | Pirate Club | 2008 |
| Kevin Kelly | Pirate Club | 2008 |
| Robert Santore | Pirate Club | 2008 |
| 1954 Basketball Team | Pirate Club | 2008 |
| Joseph Waters | Man of the Year | 2008 |
| Janet Hagan '66 | Alumni Achiever | 2008 |
| James M. Diamond '67 | Alumni Achiever | 2008 |
| Mark A. Angelo, M.D. '90 | Alumni Achiever | 2008 |
| Francis T. Foti | Abbot Pennings Award | 2008 |
| Edward Budwin | Pirate Club | 2007 |
| James W. Fynes | Pirate Club | 2007 |
| Thomas F. McCaffery | Pirate Club | 2007 |
| William J. Latta '70 | Man of the Year | 2007 |
| Joseph J. Bisicchia '82 | Alumni Achiever | 2007 |
| Louis E. Sarcone '52 | Alumni Achiever | 2007 |
| Joseph C. Waters '71 | Alumni Achiever | 2007 |
| Anthony J. DeCarlo '58 | Abbot Pennings Award | 2007 |
| Joseph Boylan | Pirate Club | 2006 |
| Vincent Campolongo | Pirate Club | 2006 |
| Michael Corba | Pirate Club | 2006 |
| Ralph DiMeo | Pirate Club | 2006 |
| Damon Reid | Pirate Club | 2006 |
| Pasquale Rotella | Pirate Club | 2006 |
| Michael Sutton | Pirate Club | 2006 |
| Charles Williams | Pirate Club | 2006 |
| Henry J. Clinton, Jr. '71 | Man of the Year | 2006 |
| Fredrick Williams | Honorary Member | 2006 |
| Mr. Frederick Williams | Honorary Member | 2006 |
| Michael J. Chitwood '61 | Alumni Achiever | 2006 |
| Basil L. Merenda, Esq. '75 | Alumni Achiever | 2006 |
| Richard A. Zappile '63 | Alumni Achiever | 2006 |
| Dr. Louis Papa '61 | Abbott Pennings Award | 2006 |
| Dr. Louis Papa '61 | Abbot Pennings Award | 2006 |
| Mr. Louis F. Brusico '52 | Pirate Club | 2005 |
| Mr. John R. Catanio '52 | Pirate Club | 2005 |
| Mr. Charles Ferrante '76 | Pirate Club | 2005 |
| Dr. Joseph Leonetti '76 | Pirate Club | 2005 |
| Peter Postiglione '54 | Man of the Year | 2005 |
| John Connolly '70 | Alumni Achiever | 2005 |
| Aldo Magazzeni '68 | Alumni Achiever | 2005 |
| Aldo Magazzeni '68 | Alumni Achiever | 2005 |
| Agustine P. Sarno '67 | Alumni Achiever | 2005 |
| Paul Phillips '41 | Abbott Pennings Award | 2005 |
| 1953 Baseball Team '53 | Pirate Club | 2004 |
| Mr. Albert Barbieri '76 | Pirate Club | 2004 |
| Mr. Walter Belovitz '70 | Pirate Club | 2004 |
| Mr. Frank Caccuro '89 | Pirate Club | 2004 |
| Mr. Ernest Cimadamore '79 | Pirate Club | 2004 |
| Mr. Jason DiEgidio '85 | Pirate Club | 2004 |
| Mr. Robert Fiss '86 | Pirate Club | 2004 |
| Mr. Frank Giunta '86 | Pirate Club | 2004 |
| Mr. Francis Seeley '69 | Pirate Club | 2004 |
| Mr. Michael LaPergola '67 | Man of the Year | 2004 |
| Mr. Paul J. Bartolomeo, Jr. Esq. | Alumni Achiever | 2004 |
| Mr. George C. Cavallo | Alumni Achiever | 2004 |
| Rev. Msgr. Arthur J. Centrella | Alumni Achiever | 2004 |
| Mr. Edward J. McBride '55 | Abbott Pennings Award | 2004 |
| Mr. William J. Anastasi '51 | Pirate Club | 2003 |
| Mr. Timothy Barry '82 | Pirate Club | 2003 |
| Mr. Gene E. Burgese '58 | Pirate Club | 2003 |
| Mr. James D. Greider '49 | Pirate Club | 2003 |
| Mr. Raymond Lardani '56 | Pirate Club | 2003 |
| Mr. James Masino '86 | Pirate Club | 2003 |
| Mr. Daryl Nelson '88 | Pirate Club | 2003 |
| Mr. Brian Barry '94 | Man Of The Year | 2003 |
| Mr. Robert W. Craig '56 | Pirate Club | 2002 |
| Mr. Albert A. Delvecchio '51 | Pirate Club | 2002 |
| Mr. William Kelleher '42 | Pirate Club | 2002 |
| Mr. Walter T. Klauder '57 | Pirate Club | 2002 |
| Mr. Raymond J. Liberatore '52 | Pirate Club | 2002 |
| Mr. Michael G. Malatesta '74 | Pirate Club | 2002 |
| Mr. Patrick J. McLaughlin '76 | Pirate Club | 2002 |
| Mr. Frank V. Rodano '53 | Pirate Club | 2002 |
| Mr. Joseph Rullo '62 | Pirate Club | 2002 |
| Mr. Joseph L. Turchi '76 | Pirate Club | 2002 |
| Mr. Bob Pantano ' 67 | Man of the Year | 2002 |
| Mr. Joseph Sphuler | Honorary Member | 2002 |
| Mr. Michael A. Carrozza '55 | Alumni Achiever | 2002 |
| Rev. David Diamond '75 | Alumni Achiever | 2002 |
| Mr. James Mulvihill '60 | Alumni Achiever | 2002 |
| Mr. Charles Temparali '61 | Alumni Achiever | 2002 |
| Mr. William J. Kelly '53 | Abbott Pennings Award | 2002 |
| Mr. Steven Benton '85 | Pirate Club | 2001 |
| Mr. Howard C. Cooper '52 | Pirate Club | 2001 |
| Mr. Michael DeLuca '76 | Pirate Club | 2001 |
| Mr. Dominic DiCicco '83 | Pirate Club | 2001 |
| Mr. Michael Fitzsimmons '83 | Pirate Club | 2001 |
| Mr. Marc Marrone '86 | Pirate Club | 2001 |
| Mr. James McElhone '70 | Pirate Club | 2001 |
| Mr. Patrick McGinley '60 | Pirate Club | 2001 |
| Mr. Michael Morrissey '68 | Pirate Club | 2001 |
| Mr. William P. Power '49 | Pirate Club | 2001 |
| Mr. Henry Lewandowski III, '92 | Man Of The Year | 2001 |
| Mrs. Eleanor Higgins | Honorary Member | 2001 |
| Mrs. Elaine Speziale | Honorary Member | 2001 |
| Mr. Thomas M. LoCasale '56 | Alumni Achiever | 2001 |
| Mr. Samuel Longo '73 | Alumni Achiever | 2001 |
| Mr. John C. McDevitt '53 | Alumni Achiever | 2001 |
| Mr. John P. Mullen '44 | Alumni Achiever | 2001 |
| Mr. Dominic R. Lettieri '50 | Abbott Pennings Award | 2001 |
| Rev. Micahel S. Olivere | School President | 2000 |
| Mr. Lawrence Barretta '83 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. Anthony Catanio '53 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. William A. Conway '40 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. Luis DeVelasco | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. Robert Goodrich '54 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. James P. Hopkins '46 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. Thomas Kahriger '60 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. Robert V. McLaughlin '55 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. Michael A. Nardi '53 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. Leonard Nelson '84 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. Richard Tait '76 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. Richard Yannelli '78 | Pirate Club | 2000 |
| Mr. Charles J. Dick '52 | Man of the Year | 2000 |
| Mr. James Conboy '58 | Directors | 2000 |
| Mr. Robert M. Vetrone '43 | Directors | 2000 |
| Mr. Richard Furia '63 | Alumni Achiever | 2000 |
| Mr. Joseph Kaufmann '69 | Alumni Achiever | 2000 |
| Mr. Anthony Verna '51 | Alumni Achiever | 2000 |
| Mr. Mark Viggiano '73 | Alumni Achiever | 2000 |
| Mr. Edward J. Heffernan '52 | Abbott Pennings Award | 2000 |
| Mr. Louis Cambria '79 | Pirate Club | 1999 |
| Mr. James DeRenzi '79 | Pirate Club | 1999 |
| Mr. Edward DiCamillo '65 | Pirate Club | 1999 |
| Mr. George J. Dominic '47 | Pirate Club | 1999 |
| Mr. Francis X. Heffernan '44 | Pirate Club | 1999 |
| Mr. Anthony F. Herner '58 | Pirate Club | 1999 |
| Mr. Francis McCaney '44 | Pirate Club | 1999 |
| Mr. Charles Muzio '53 | Pirate Club | 1999 |
| Mr. Henry Sirolli '74 | Pirate Club | 1999 |
| Mr. Francis R. Squilla '53 | Pirate Club | 1999 |
| Mr. Larry Ciletti '58 | Man Of The Year | 1999 |
| Mr. Ed Welsh | Honorary Member | 1999 |
| Mr. Bob Pantano | Directors Award | 1999 |
| Mr. James L. Coleman, Jr. '58 | Alumni Achiever | 1999 |
| Mr. James F. Harron '61 | Alumni Achiever | 1999 |
| Mr. John Ligato '65 | Alumni Achiever | 1999 |
| Mr. George Litto '49 | Alumni Achiever | 1999 |
| Mr. John Francesco '60 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1999 |
| Rev. John Zagarella, O.Praem | School President | 1998 |
| Mr. Albert Colleluori | Principal | 1998 |
| Mr. Robert Agnes '76 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. Salvatore Amaradio '75 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. John M. Bonavitacola '51 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. Edward Braceland '77 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. Vincent P. DiCintio '48 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. Ronald Docimo '71 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. Anthony Iannacone '36 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. Joseph Kelly '53 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. John Leonard '79 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. Harry A. Short '48 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. John Sica '67 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Mr. Thomas L. Weick '47 | Pirate Club | 1998 |
| Peter Certo '84 | Man Of The Year | 1998 |
| Dr. Joseph Donnelly | Honorary Member | 1998 |
| Mrs. Helen Marinelli | Honorary Member | 1998 |
| Msgr Alexander Palmieri | Alumni Achiever | 1998 |
| Mr. John R. Taylor | Alumni Achiever | 1998 |
| Mr. Joseph Vassalluzzo | Alumni Achiever | 1998 |
| Thomas F. Mellett | Abbott Pennings Award | 1998 |
| Giacomo Apadula | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Donald Capone | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Dalmazio DiCristofaro | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| John Donahue | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| John Dunn | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Harry Echtermeyer | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Joseph Keenan | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Theophilus Lloyd | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| James Malseed | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Thomas McAveney | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| John Myers | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Louis Penna | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Stephen Perna | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Anthony Pugliese | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Paul Ruffenach | Pirate Club | 1997 |
| Joseph Petrarca '62 | Man Of The Year | 1997 |
| Mrs. Dorothy B. Longo | Honorary Member | 1997 |
| Mr. Steven W. Dezii '69 | Alumni Achiever | 1997 |
| Mr. Charles Dick '78 | Alumni Achiever | 1997 |
| Rev. William A. Dombrow '57 | Alumni Achiever | 1997 |
| Mr. William D. Valente '42 | Alumni Achiever | 1997 |
| Mr. John J. Ardizzi '47 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1997 |
| Rev. John Zagarella, O.Praem | Principal | 1996 |
| Mr. Frank J. Baldassarre '49 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Frank S. Blatcher '47 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Michael Brennan '67 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Charles Campbell '80 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. James F. Conway '45 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Nicholas J. D'Antonio '55 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Joseph DiPietro '80 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Robert Fleming '76 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Francis Fletcher '69 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. John J. Furlow '47 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Patrick J. McCann '61 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Michael Nardi '65 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Randal Scotti '75 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Mr. Patrick Shanahan '80 | Pirate Club | 1996 |
| Michael J. Crumsho '53 | Man Of The Year | 1996 |
| Mr. Thomas Cozy Morley '44 | Directors | 1996 |
| Mr. Phelim F. Dean, Jr. '45 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1996 |
| Mike Adam's '72 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| John Amorim '78 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| Joseph S. Cannull '44 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| George Chew '55 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| Nicholas Colucci '61 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| Michael DiBenedetto '67 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| Thomas Henderson '53 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| Harry Marnie '61 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| Raymond Norton '54 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| Eugene Prybella '70 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| LLoyd Ranson '74 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| Robert E. Senske '45 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| Andrew Schuda, Jr. '67 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| James Stinger '64 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| Ralph Zagrabbe '68 | Pirate Club | 1995 |
| William Campbell '56 | Man Of The Year | 1995 |
| John Nigrelli '58 | Man Of The Year | 1995 |
| Rev. Alfred A. McBride, O.PRAEM | Alumni Achiever | 1995 |
| Mr. John Malone '42 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1995 |
| Charles Bastian '54 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| Harry Booth '57 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| Rev. John Cimino '53 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| James Forsythe '45 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| James Golden '67 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| Joseph Jacovini '58 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| Hank Mazzola '65 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| Nick Runtagh '42 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| Robert Smith '72 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| John Smith '76 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| Vince Volpe '70 | Pirate Club | 1994 |
| William Screnci '70 | Man Of The Year | 1994 |
| Herbert Melick '36 | Director's Award | 1994 |
| Harry Harp '41 | Alumni Achiever | 1994 |
| Rev. Mr. John Orlando '48 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1994 |
| Rev. Michael Lee, O. Praem | School President | 1993 |
| Rev. Ronald Rossi, O.Praem | Principal | 1993 |
| George Belka '65 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Basil DiSipio '71 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Daniel Dougherty '44 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Edmund Garstkiewicz '48 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| James Gaynor '66 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Albert Hall '64 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Francis Henkel '44 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Stephen McKenna '56 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Anthony Mignogna '75 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Joseph Moshinski '53 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Gerard Smith '77 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| James Wagner '63 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Henry White '61 | Pirate Club | 1993 |
| Joseph Hammond '52 | Man Of The Year | 1993 |
| John Barbagiovanni,D.O. '58 | Alumni Achiever | 1993 |
| John DeMaio,M.D. '74 | Alumni Achiever | 1993 |
| John L. Goodyear '54 | Alumni Achiever | 1993 |
| Edward F. McGehrin | Alumni Achiever | 1993 |
| Mr. Paul Perrillo | Abbott Pennings Award | 1993 |
| Rev. Michael Lee, O.Praem. | Principal | 1992 |
| Frank Abruzzese '65 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Louis Centani '41 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Reginald DeCarlo '59 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Dennis Ferguson '65 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Richard Gagliardi '49 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Charles Hannan '42 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Ronald Hill '64 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Albert Kunberger '46 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Gene Mattioli '77 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Michael McSweeney '60 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Thomas Quinn '43 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Peter Sandusky '51 | Pirate Club | 1992 |
| Carmen Marrone '61 | Man Of The Year | 1992 |
| Bro. Richard G. Cannuli '64 | Alumni Achiever | 1992 |
| Dr. Joseph A. Leonetti '76 | Alumni Achiever | 1992 |
| Richard A. Nardella '59 | Alumni Achiever | 1992 |
| Hon. Louis J. Presenza '63 | Alumni Achiever | 1992 |
| Mr. Richard Tate | Abbott Pennings Award | 1992 |
| Frederick Anthony '56 | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| Frank Anthony | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| Joseph Dulczak '41 | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| Hugh Jeffers | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| Edward Lamb '70 | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| Bro. Jmaes Love, O.Praem. '59 | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| Anthony Malerba '69 | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| Martin McLaughlin '51 | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| Joseph Pooler '55 | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| John Solari '50 | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| Louis Solari '52 | Pirate Club | 1991 |
| Louis W. Screnci | Man Of The Year | 1991 |
| William P. Mannion '41 | Director's Award | 1991 |
| F. Robert Dieter '48 | Alumni Achiever | 1991 |
| Richard J. Fruncillo, M.D. '71 | Alumni Achiever | 1991 |
| William F. Ryder, Jr. '41 | Alumni Achiever | 1991 |
| Harry A. Short '48 | Alumni Achiever | 1991 |
| Richard Kearney '40 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1991 |
| Edward J. McBride '55 | President | 1990 |
| William Bailey '45 | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| Bob Capone '58 | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| Frank Ciaciak '60 | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| Hank Clinton '44 | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| Dennis Collins '51 | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| John DiFeliciantonio '73 | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| Charlie Hodge '66 | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| Tom Kennedy '40 | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| Sal Leonardo '50 | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| Bob Matthews | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| Edmond Toscani '42 | Pirate Club | 1990 |
| James Eastwood '63 | Man Of The Year | 1990 |
| William A. Conway '40 | Alumni Achiever | 1990 |
| Thomas J. Hanratty '44 | Alumni Achiever | 1990 |
| Henry G. Mazzola '65 | Alumni Achiever | 1990 |
| William P. Rohlfing '45 | Alumni Achiever | 1990 |
| John T. Riordan '63 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1990 |
| Charles Bagocius '36 | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| Anthony Capuano '55 | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| Albert DiGiacomo | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| Walter Haas '43 | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| Thomas Halpin '50 | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| William Hatty '71 | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| James Joyce '56 | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| Fred Laterza '50 | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| John Lipsett '40 | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| Joseph McBride | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| Samuel Stavola '37 | Pirate Club | 1989 |
| James Tully '40 | Man Of The Year | 1989 |
| Frank A. Abruzzese '65 | Alumni Achiever | 1989 |
| Rev. Joseph McCloskey, U.S.N. '51 | Alumni Achiever | 1989 |
| Frederic J. Stinson '47 | Alumni Achiever | 1989 |
| James L. Williams '44 | Alumni Achiever | 1989 |
| George Parker '50 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1989 |
| Robert Atene '67 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| Frank Borrelli '61 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| Francis Burke '38 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| Bernard Burke '40 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| Anthony DelConte '51 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| Patrick Drass '58 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| William Fair '40 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| George Fair '40 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| James Furey '46 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| Anthony Latronica '51 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| Joseph McDonald '44 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| Joseph Sirolli '70 | Pirate Club | 1988 |
| Rev. Richard Antonucci, O.Praem. '63 | Man Of The Year | 1988 |
| Bobby Rydell | Director's Award | 1988 |
| William T. Bergman | Alumni Achiever | 1988 |
| John S. Nigrelli '58 | Alumni Achiever | 1988 |
| Ernest J. Sabato '55 | Alumni Achiever | 1988 |
| Leonard DeMasi '67 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1988 |
| Rev. Richard Antonucci, O.Praem | Principal | 1987 |
| William Boegly '55 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| Arthur Bove '37 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| Raymond Chioumento '60 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| Bernard Gallagher '40 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| Joseph Gorman '45 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| William Kelly '53 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| Edward Kerley '40 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| Michael LaPergola '67 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| Joseph Naselli '65 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| William Oakes '62 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| Joseph Schultz '49 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| James Tobin '55 | Pirate Club | 1987 |
| Frank Maurone '44 | Man Of The Year | 1987 |
| Gerard Iannelli '38 | Director's Award | 1987 |
| James W. Eastwood '63 | Alumni Achiever | 1987 |
| Joseph H. Jacovini '58 | Alumni Achiever | 1987 |
| Gerald P. McBride | Alumni Achiever | 1987 |
| Rev. Domenic A. Rossi, O.Praem. '66 | Alumni Achiever | 1987 |
| Edward McNichol '39 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1987 |
| Michael Barrett '65 | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| James Curran '39 | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| Thomas Delany '46 | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| Joseph DiGrazio '53 | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| Louis Fiorella '40 | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| Earl Geissler '61 | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| Jack Kraft | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| Anthony Marrollo '47 | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| John McGarry | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| Terence McLaughlin '53 | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| Joseph Russell '65 | Pirate Club | 1986 |
| Robert Senske '45 | Man Of The Year | 1986 |
| Daniel Parrillo '67 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1986 |
| Robert Capone '58 | President | 1985 |
| Frank Gillen '40 | Pirate Club | 1985 |
| Frank Gillen '65 | Pirate Club | 1985 |
| Michael Goffredo '49 | Pirate Club | 1985 |
| George Guida '40 | Pirate Club | 1985 |
| Joseph Lavin '53 | Pirate Club | 1985 |
| Richard Mattioli '59 | Pirate Club | 1985 |
| Jack McDonnell '52 | Pirate Club | 1985 |
| William Mulvihill '58 | Pirate Club | 1985 |
| Robert Oristaglio '42 | Pirate Club | 1985 |
| George Seeber '38 | Pirate Club | 1985 |
| Joseph Ruffenach '48 | Man Of The Year | 1985 |
| Alan Frio '65 | Director's Award | 1985 |
| John Finnegan '47 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1985 |
| Rev. William Leonard, O.Praem | Principal | 1984 |
| William Brannau '49 | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| Dr. Salvatore Cucinotta | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| Anthony Derago '46 | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| Tom DiMuzio '66 | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| Larry Faust '46 | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| Rev. George Feider, O.Praem | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| James Gannon '58 | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| Rev. John Mokluk '58 | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| Franny Moock '36 | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| Rev. Joseph Rohlinger | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| Andy Terifay '59 | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| William Woods '38 | Pirate Club | 1984 |
| Robert Capone '58 | Man Of The Year | 1984 |
| Joseph Grady | Director's Award | 1984 |
| Ralph Desiderio '56 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1984 |
| John J. McLaughlin '51 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1984 |
| Rev. Walter J. Burke, O.Praem. '37 | Pirate Club | 1983 |
| Charles Chew '58 | Pirate Club | 1983 |
| Edward Cook '50 | Pirate Club | 1983 |
| Alfred Famiglietti '59 | Pirate Club | 1983 |
| James Grazione '55 | Pirate Club | 1983 |
| James Hannan '39 | Pirate Club | 1983 |
| Michael Hannan '41 | Pirate Club | 1983 |
| Joseph Hannan '45 | Pirate Club | 1983 |
| John Lavin '51 | Pirate Club | 1983 |
| Basil DiSipio '71 | Man Of The Year | 1983 |
| John "Jake" Jordan '42 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1983 |
| Walter Belovitz '70 | President | 1982 |
| Paul J. Bartolomeo | Pirate Club | 1982 |
| James McCullough '75 | Man Of The Year | 1982 |
| Daniel Dougherty | Director's Award | 1982 |
| Joseph O'Brien '44 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1982 |
| Rev. Robert Gaghan, O.Praem. | Principal | 1981 |
| Peter Spina '76 | Man Of The Year | 1981 |
| Dr. James Kirchske '60 | Director's Award | 1981 |
| Michael Chitwood '61 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1981 |
| Rev. Edward Smith, O.Praem. | Principal | 1980 |
| Louis DeAngelo '76 | Man Of The Year | 1980 |
| Dr. Paul Carmichael '44 | Director's Award | 1980 |
| Leonard Foti '41 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1980 |
| Walter Belovitz '70 | Man Of The Year | 1979 |
| Patrick Nolan '50 | Director's Award | 1979 |
| James Kearney '50 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1979 |
| Gerard Iannelli '38 | President | 1978 |
| Joseph Tobey '64 | Man Of The Year | 1978 |
| Rev. Martin Frigo, O.Praem '42 | Man Of The Year | 1977 |
| Rev. Anthony W. Polini, O.Praem '42 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1977 |
| Anthony Valeriano '47 | Man Of The Year | 1976 |
| Dennis "bud" McNichol '38 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1976 |
| Bro. James Love, O.Praem. '59 | Man Of The Year | 1975 |
| Rev. John Cox, O.Praem. | Principal | 1974 |
| Joseph Tobey '64 | President | 1974 |
| Frank Foti '44 | Man Of The Year | 1974 |
| John McHenry '47 | Man Of The Year | 1973 |
| William Stewart '52 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1973 |
| Edward McBride '55 | Man Of The Year | 1972 |
| Frank Baldassarre '49 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1972 |
| Frank Perri '49 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1972 |
| Michael Murray '44 | Man Of The Year | 1971 |
| Msgr. Francis Statkus, J.C.D. '38 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1971 |
| John McLaughlin | President | 1970 |
| John McLaughlin '51 | Man Of The Year | 1970 |
| William Kelly '53 | Man Of The Year | 1969 |
| Henry "Hank" Clinton '44 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1969 |
| Samuel Paolella '43 | Man Of The Year | 1968 |
| Rev. Anthony Polini, O.Praem | Principal | 1967 |
| Peter Pacitti '43 | Man Of The Year | 1967 |
| William Valente '42 | Abbott Pennings Award | 1967 |
| Rev. William Fenning, O.Praem. '39 | Man Of The Year | 1966 |
| William Kelly '53 | President | 1965 |
| Gerard Ianelli '38 | Man Of The Year | 1965 |
| George Seeber '38 | Man Of The Year | 1965 |
| Rev. John Cagney, O.Praem. | Principal | 1964 |
| Edward Rideout '56 | President | 1964 |
| James Quinn '48 | Man Of The Year | 1964 |
| Joseph DiSipio '39 | President | 1963 |
| Rev. Joseph Kelly, O.Praem. '40 | Man Of The Year | 1963 |
| Richard Kearney '40 | Man Of The Year | 1962 |
| Rev. John Neitzel, O.Praem. | Principal | 1961 |
| James Quinn '48 | President | 1961 |
| Joseph DiSipio '39 | Man Of The Year | 1961 |
| James Phillips '44 | Man Of The Year | 1960 |
| James Phillips '44 | President | 1959 |
| Michael Juliano '36 | Man Of The Year | 1959 |
| Louis Lister | Man Of The Year | 1958 |
| Edward Smith '36 | President | 1957 |
| Rev. Walter J. Burke, O.Praem. '37 | Man Of The Year | 1957 |
| Rev. Anthony W. Polini, O.Praem. '42 | Man Of The Year | 1957 |
| Frank Palmieri '42 | Man Of The Year | 1956 |
| Daniel Dougherty | Man Of The Year | 1955 |
| Rev. Albert Koob, O.Praem | Principal | 1954 |
| Daniel Dougherty '44 | President | 1954 |
| Edward Smith | Man Of The Year | 1954 |
| Paul Phillips '41 | Man Of The Year | 1953 |
| Paul Phillips '41 | President | 1950 |
| Gerard Ianelli | President | 1948 |
| Rev. Julian Resch, O.Praem. | Principal | 1946 |
| Edward Osborne '37 | President | 1946 |
| Rev. L.A.V. DeCleene, O.Praem. | Principal | 1945 |
| John McNamee '36 | President | 1945 |
| John Hannan '39 | President | 1943 |
| Louis Lister '38 | President | 1942 |
| John Artman '36 | President | 1940 |
| Herb Melick '36 | President | 1938 |
| Rev. Michael McKeough, O.Praem. | Principal | 1936 |
| Rev. Hubert Traeger, O.Praem. | Principal | 1934 |
| Paul Bartolomeo | Honorary Member | |
| Anthony Cardinal Bevilacqua | Honorary Member | |
| Walter Burke | Honorary Member | |
| Fr. John Cagney, O.Praem. | Honorary Member | |
| Barry Carey | Honorary Member | |
| Larry Ciletti | Honorary Member | |
| Frank Cobb | Honorary Member | |
| Nina Cobb | Honorary Member | |
| James Conboy | Honorary Member | |
| Rev. Michael Dean | Honorary Member | |
| Luis DeVelasco | Honorary Member | |
| Albert DiGiacomo | Honorary Member | |
| Elizabeth "Betty" DiPietro | Honorary Member | |
| Mary Donofrio | Honorary Member | |
| Marian Fair | Honorary Member | |
| Rev. George Feider, O.Praem. | Honorary Member | |
| Elvira Fiore | Honorary Member | |
| Marie Fitzpatrick | Honorary Member | |
| Rev. Martin Frigo, O.Praem. | Honorary Member | |
| John Gross | Honorary Member | |
| Ann Hayes | Honorary Member | |
| James J. Kearney, Jr. | Honorary Member | |
| John Kraft | Honorary Member | |
| Rev. Francis McHugh, O.Praem. | Honorary Member | |
| Amelia McLaughlin | Honorary Member | |
| Rev. John Neitzel, O.Praem. | Honorary Member | |
| John Pacitti | Honorary Member | |
| Michael Scavo | Honorary Member | |
| Beulah Stoner | Honorary Member | |
| Maryann Varalli | Honorary Member | |
| Hon. Anna Verna | Honorary Member | |
| Frank Weiner | Honorary Member | |
| Walter Weinrich | Honorary Member | |
